some information about Iranian women

 

Sign the ON-LINE petition to save Nazanin & Kobra from execution in Iran

http://www.save-kobrae.blogfa.com/

 

web log

http://www.helpnazanin.com/Updates.aspx#20060917

 

film about Nazanin

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdOP40AAv00

 

Open letter To Kofi Anan and human rights bodies

Ladies and gentlemen!

http://www.save-kobrae.blogfa.com/post-13.aspx

 

A Number of convicts to execution and stoning, demand authorities of human rights bodies and organizations and United Nations for help and demand you to sincerely ask Iranian government to nullify execution and stoning decrees.

 

These convicts still don’t know their situation after the years. They say that:” every day and moment we “live” with horrible thought of the execution rope and stones being thrown at us. Every now and then they review our cases and confirm our execution or stoning decree. We are all victims of situations of society ourselves. We are victims of poverty and tyranny. You may not understand this kind of life. We live every moment of our life in prison under the emotional torture and all our existence has become emptied from life. We don’t want to be killed or to suffer under these pressures to the extent of madness and desperation.”

 

Ladies and Gentlemen!

There is a law in Iran calledQasas” (Nemesis) which has given convicts life to slain’s family. Some of these convicts have lived for years expecting these families for mercy or bestowal. Years and years of not knowing your situation, in prison and with the permanent thought and scare of execution is not a life, but a horrible nightmare.

They expect United Nations to do something to abolish the law of Nemesis (Qasas) and Stoning.

We want you all to help us so these humans can be released from this inhumane situation and to nullify their execution and stoning decree. Join us to give these people another life and to liberate them from prison!

Convicts that are waiting for their cases:

Akram Qavi-del

Akhtar Mohamadi Monfared

Tayebe Hojati

Azam Ghare shiran

Shahla Jahed

Kobra Rahmanpour

Nazanin Fatehi

Fateme Haghighat-pajooh

 

The list is not exhausted.

Campaign to save Kobra’s life

www.save-kobra.blogfa.com

campagne.kobra@gmail.com

 

September 29th 2006

Dear friends!

We have got this requests from the heart of prisons. Many prisoners who have lived for years not knowing what to do and between life and death, have demanded us to write for United Nations and human rights bodies to help this convicts and put an end to their nightmares. We want you all to give this letter to execution convicts all over the Iran so they can add their names if they want. For this we would need the first and last name of prisoner, the reason of execution decree, the name of prison and also the name of Prisoner’s lawyer. Help us to make a more complete list

 

Execution Of A Teenage Girl

film

On August 15th 2004, a 16-year-old girl was hanged in a public square in Neka, Iran, a small industrial town by the Caspian Sea. Her death sentence was for crimes against chastity. Her name was Atefah Sahaaleh. The only evidence against Atefah was her own forced confession. Atefah railed against her judge in court for its unfairness, but this was her undoing. Judge Haji Rezai, who was also the local mullah, prosecutor and head of the city administration, personally obtained permission from Iran's Supreme Court to execute her, and put the noose around her neck himself before she was hoisted on a crane jib arm to her death. Using undercover footage, eyewitness accounts and drama reconstruction, this film tells an unforgettable story of the life and tragic death of an ordinary teenage girl under Iran's mullahs.
Shown on BBC2 in the UK on 27th July 2006

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHqnSe3EqpA

 

Women in Iran 2006

Film

Video clip *say NO* Iran 09 März 2006

 

http://www.dailymotion.com/farshad/video/x1mus_womens-day-tehran

 

8 march in Tehran 2006

 

http://www.dailymotion.com/farshad/video/x1l4b_8-march-in-tehran

 

Police Rush 2006

http://www.dailymotion.com/farshad/video/x1l4e_police-rush

 

police is coming 2006

 

http://www.dailymotion.com/farshad/video/x1l4c_police-is-coming

 

Police Attack 2006

 

http://www.dailymotion.com/farshad/video/x1l4d_police-attack

 

women long March from Germany to Den Haag 2006 *film

 

http://www.8mars.com/soti/film/8%20Marts%20real.rm

 

more film 2005 / 50MB

 

http://meydaan.com/UserFiles/Media/01.mpg

 

1MB

 

http://www.pouyashome.com/weblog/movietest.htm

 

Thousands of Iranian women gathered in Tehran demanding equal rights on June 12, 2006. The demonstration inTehran was viciously attacked by military forces and led to the arrest of 60 demonstrators. Although the majority have been released, Mr.Mosavai Khomeini-ha remains in prison. Human Rights Watch has twice requested Iranian authorities for his immediate release

 

A feminist gathering in 7-Tir square of Tehran, in protest of the unequal rights and discriminatory laws against women in Iran, which was violently interrupted by the police, and dozens were arrested

 

June 12, 2006 Photos

 

http://www.rassaa.com/

 

http://www.kosoof.com/archive/281.php

 

Stoning in Iran (Old film)

 

http://www.apostatesofislam.com/media/video/stoning_video_100kbps.wmv

 

To:  The Judiciary Chief of Iran

http://meydaan.com/petition.aspx?cid=46&pid=2

 

Petition to save Ashraf Kalhori from death by stoning

http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?AshrafK

 

Cc: The Iranian Parliament Representatives

 

We are deeply concerned that Ashraf Kalhori, a 37-year-old mother of four, has been sentenced to death for having had an extramarital relationship.

 

We are further concerned that she has been sentenced to death by stoning. Death by stoning is one of the most inhumane acts of torturous execution, where the convict is buried alive in a pit with her sheet-covered head exposed outside to be smashed by marble-sized rocks that are thrown by the members of the community.

 

We would like to remind you that as the chief of the Islamic Republic of Iran s Judiciary, you have ordered a ban on the execution of all cases of stoning as of April, 2001. Hereby, we request that you use your authority as the Judiciary Chief, to enforce such ban and stop the execution of Ashraf Kalhori.

 

At the same time, we are asking the Iranian Parliament representatives to change the criminal law so that an extramarital relationship is not considered a "crime" and that it certainly does not warrant the death penalty.

 

Sincerely 

 

The Undersigned

PUBLIC
AI Index: MDE 13/113/2006
28 September 2006

UA 257/06

Death penalty/ stoning
http://www2.amnesty.se/uaonnet.nsf/Senaste+veckan/20F6C39541922492C12571F8002E0E3D?opendocument


IRAN
Parisa (f) ]
Iran (f)] full names known to Amnesty International
Khayrieh (f)]
Shamameh Ghorbani (also known as Malek) (f)
Kobra Najjar (f, aged 44)
Soghra Mola'i (f)
Fatemeh (f)

The women named above are at risk of execution by stoning.

Parisa was arrested in April 2004, while working as a prostitute in the city of Shiraz in southern Iran. She confessed to the charge of adultery during the preliminary investigations, claiming that she had been forced into prostitution by her husband due to the family's poverty. Her trial took place in June 2004, during which Parisa retracted her confession. Nevertheless, on 21 June 2004, Branch 5 of Fars province Criminal Court sentenced her to death by stoning for adultery. The sentence was upheld by Branch 32 of the Supreme Court on 15 November 2005. Her case is currently being reviewed by the Supreme Court. Parisa is detained in Adelabad prison in Shiraz.

Iran, an Ahwazi Arab from the Bakhtiari clan, was reportedly talking to the son of a neighbour in the courtyard of her house, when her husband attacked her with a knife. She was badly beaten and left bleeding and unconscious on the floor. While she was unconscious, it is alleged that the man killed her husband with his own knife. While police were interrogating her about the killing, Iran reportedly confessed to adultery with the son of her neighbour. However she later retracted her confession. A court in a city in Khuzestan sentenced her to five years' imprisonment for being an accomplice in the murder of her husband, and to execution by stoning for adultery. The verdict was upheld by the Supreme Court in April 2006. Her lawyer has appealed against the sentence. She is detained in Sepidar prison, in Ahvaz city.

Khayrieh, an Ahwazi Arab, was reportedly subjected to domestic violence by her husband. She allegedly began an affair with a relative of her husband, who then murdered him. She was sentenced to death by Branch 3 of Behbahan Court, in Khuzestan in southwestern Iran, for being an accomplice in the murder of her husband, and death by stoning for adultery. Khayrieh has denied any involvement in her husband's murder, but confessed to adultery. The sentence was upheld, and the case has reportedly been sent to the Head of the Judiciary for permission to be implemented. Talking about her fate, Khayrieh said "I am ready to be hanged, but they should not stone me. They could strangle you and you would die, but it is very difficult to have stones hitting you in the head".

Shamameh Ghorbani (also known as Malek), arrested in June 2005, was sentenced to execution by stoning for adultery by a court in Oromieh in June 2006. She is reportedly held in Oromieh prison. Her brothers and husband reportedly murdered a man that they found in her house, and she too was nearly killed after they stabbed her with a knife. Shamameh Ghorbani's case is reportedly being re-examined.

Kobra Najjar, who is detained in Tabriz prison in northwestern Iran, is at imminent risk of execution. She was sentenced to eight years' imprisonment for being an accomplice to the murder of her husband, and execution by stoning for adultery. She was scheduled to be executed after serving her prison sentence, which was finished two years ago. She has reportedly written to the Judicial Commission for Amnesty to ask for her sentence of execution by stoning to be commuted, and is awaiting a reply. Kobra Najjar was allegedly forced into prostitution by her husband, a heroin addict who was violent towards her. In 1995, after a severe beating by her husband, she told one of her regular customers that she wanted to kill her husband. The customer allegedly murdered her husband after Kobra Najjar took him to an arranged meeting place. He was sentenced to death, but he was pardoned by the victim's family, to whom he paid diyeh (blood money).

Soghra Mola'i was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment for being an accomplice to the murder in January 2004 of her husband Abdollah, and to execution by stoning for adultery. During interrogation she said "My husband usually tormented me. Nevertheless, I did not intend to kill him. On the night of the incident … after Alireza killed my husband, I ran away with him because I was scared to stay at home, thinking that my brothers-in-law would kill me." Alireza was sentenced to death for the murder of Soghra Mola'i's husband, and to 100 lashes for "illicit relations". The sentences are pending examination by the Supreme Court. It is believed that Soghra Mola'i is detained in Reja'i Shahr prison, Karaj, near Tehran.

In May 2005, Branch 71 of the Tehran Province Criminal Court sentenced Fatemeh (surname unknown) to retribution (qesas) for being an accomplice to murder, and execution by stoning for having an 'illicit relationship' with a man named Mahmoud. Her husband was sentenced to 16 years' imprisonment for being an accomplice to the murder of Mahmoud. The case is currently being examined in the Supreme Court. According to a May 2005 report in the newspaper Etemad, an altercation occurred between Mahmoud, and Fatimah’s husband. Fatemeh confessed to tying a rope around Mahmud’s throat, which resulted in his strangulation. She has claimed that she intended merely to tie his hands and feet after he was unconscious and hand him over to the police.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Amnesty International is aware of two other women under sentence of execution by stoning in Iran, Ashraf Kalhori (see UA 203/06, MDE 13/083/2006, 27 July 2006; and updates), and Hajieh Esmailvand (see UA 336/04, MDE 13/053/2004, 16 December 2004; and updates). The Head of the Judiciary announced a moratorium on the use of stoning in December 2002, but reports indicate a man and a woman may have been stoned to death in May 2006.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: Please send appeals to arrive as quickly as possible, in Persian, English, Arabic or your own language:
- calling for the sentences of execution by stoning of the seven women named above (naming them) to be commuted immediately;
- stating your unconditional opposition to the death penalty, as the ultimate cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment and violation of the right to life;
- reminding the Iranian authorities that the UN Human Rights Committee (in the case of Toonen v Australia) has made clear that treating adultery and fornication as criminal offences does not comply with international human rights standards. Therefore the sentence of execution by stoning for adultery breaches Iran's commitment under article 6(2) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights that death sentences will be imposed "only for the most serious crimes";
- calling for the abolition of execution by stoning in Iran as a positive step towards implementing international law and standards for the protection of human rights.

APPEALS TO:

Leader of the Islamic Republic
His Excellency Ayatollah Sayed 'Ali Khamenei, The Office of the Supreme Leader
Shoahada Street, Qom, Islamic Republic of Iran
Email: info@leader.ir OR istiftaa@wilayah.org
Salutation: Your Excellency

Head of the Judiciary
His Excellency Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi Shahroudi
Ministry of Justice, Park-e Shahr, Tehran, Islamic Republic of Iran
Email: Please send emails via the feedback form on the Persian site of the website: http://www.iranjudiciary.org/contactus-feedback-fa.html
(The text of the feedback form translates as: 1st line: name, 2nd line: email address, 3rd line: subject heading, then enter your email into the text box)
Salutation: Your Excellency
COPIES TO: diplomatic representatives of Iran accredited to your country.
IRANS AMBASSAD
BOX 6031
181 06 LIDINGÖ
FAX 08-636 3613

PLEASE SEND APPEALS IMMEDIATELY. Check with the International Secretariat, or your section office, if sending appeals after 9 November 2006.

Source: Amnesty International, International Secretariat,
1 Easton Street, WC1X 8DJ, London, United Kingdom

 

save Kobra , Nayanin , Sina , ..........

, , ,

http://www.helpnazanin.com/, , ,

, , ,

Kobra Rahmanpoor’s open letter : I want to live!

13-Sep-2006

Kobra Rahmanpoor , From Evin prison, Tehran/Iran

I am a human being just like you. I do not want to die. However I am now a sol less body who in fear of the execution rope has forgotten how to laugh and be happy. A lot of people say to me how come your case has been so much publicized but you are still in prison? I have to tell them that I am only steps away from execution. I too like all of you am afraid of dying. Please help me so that this would not be my last letter.,

People, friends!
My mother, father and handicapped brother are very worried about me. Your supports so far have been such a comfort to them. I wish my life was different. I wish I had finished my pre-university education. I wish I did not have to be a servant for my husband. I wish I had not reached insanity. I suffered a lot and was intimidated. I am a true victim. Now they are about to hang the victim. This was not and is not my destiny.

In these dark days of fear, I urge you once again to help me. I thank all mass media and all people who supported me before. Now, may be for the last time, I urge you to do everything you can to free me from execution. I like freedom. I dream about my freedom and a good life.

I have suffered enough. Help me to get rid of the nightmare of execution which wakes me up all the time. Do what you can. There is not much time left. Every minute takes me nearer to the rope. Please help me! I am afraid of the rope and death. I hate the rope that is waiting for me on the crane. I want to live. All other doors are closed to me. Nobody helps me. My only hope is the people. I want to hold my mother and father in my arms.

I want to thank my mother, father and all who have supported me.

Kobra Rahmanpoor
From Evin prison, Tehran/Iran
Shahrivar 1385 (September 2006)

, , ,

 

, , ,

An open letter

To all noble humans, and all human right defender bodies

 

I, Abolfazl Rahmanpour, the father of Kobra Rahmanpour pledge you to protest to the unfair sentence of my young daughter.

Kobra, my young daughter, was forced to marry a man, 43 years older than herself. Kobra was a good student in her school and her wish was to study in the university but she was forced to forget all of her wishes because of the extreme poverty of the family.

Kobra had a hard life before marriage and after marriage her life became even worse. the extremeness of problems and sufferings that she had to take in a family that look at her first a servant and then a daughter-in-law, was so much that made a kind girl like her to commit a murder in an accident and while defending herself.

Kobra spent the best years of her youth in the prison and with the threat of death. She has suffered so much and has completely fall. It is so many years that she can feel the execution rope on her neck and her life goes on with sensing death, she shouldn’t suffer more tortures. When look at her colorless eyes, fallen teeth, and senseless body I always ask myself what did I do wrong? What shouldn’t I have done? Whose fault is this?

As she has said herself she wants to live and she is scared from the execution, the rope and the crane. She wants to go to university and study. Kobra is a very kind girl, her inmates can testify that. She should be free as soon as possible to go back to her normal life.

Our only hope is the protest of you noble people to this unjust sentence. The only way of preventing this sentence is the protest of all of the people, human rights defending bodies, committees against the executions and international bodies. Just for a second thought what me and Kobra’s mother are going true to realize how horrible are this days. I wouldn’t mind to be executed instead of Kobra, is that possible? I have always worked from day to night, but I don’t know why our destiny went this way? I and Kobra’s mother have no hope to life or another thing beside Kobra. Help us. Save my Family, my disabled son who always asks about her sister, Kobra, from this horror of execution of our dear Kobra. We are waiting for your definite actions. We all ask you to sign this letter. I know that there is no time and we are in last seconds. I ask for your help once more, in these last seconds. Sign this letter to show that you also demand Kobra’s Freedom.

 

Send your supports to this Email: campagne.kobra@gmail.com

 

We will declare the names of those who sign in this blog : www.save-kobra.blogfa.com

 

Women Victims of Stoning

Tue   05 09 2006  

1-Ms. Amini, you are involved in gathering information and reporting on the situation of women who have been condemned to death by stoning, and your activities have taken you to the cities of Mashhad and Jolfa in Iran. Could you please tell us about your findings?

 

In fact, in the beginning these reports were not as systematically gathered as you point to in your question. After news of two or three cases, I decided to take on this subject as a professional investigative reporter because I realized that no one was really following up and focusing on these kinds of reports.  Unfortunately there was and there still is no shortage of these types of cases and as a result I have been constantly involved in reporting and investigating for over two years and often my role has gone beyond the role of a reporter.

 

About my trips to Mashhad and Jolfa I have to say that sometime in May of 2006, one of my friends who had just returned from Mashhad informed me that two women in Mashhad had been stoned to death. I found the news strange as I knew that Mr. Shahroudi (head of Iran's judiciary, Ayatollah Mahmoud Shahroudi) had put a stop to this type of execution. It had been about five years since there had been any deaths by stoning. Although there were a few women who had been sentenced to death by stoning, because of the ban I was sure that the executions would never take place. The news of stoning if true meant that either the head of judiciary had issued a new order removing the ban on stoning or in some parts of the country people believed that they could act against the orders of the head of the judiciary. 

 

I think it was some time in the beginning of June that Ms. Ashraf Kolheri was notified by the office of the judiciary to prepare herself as her sentence of death by stoning was going to be carried out. Of course it was obvious that the situation was more serious than we thought. What was interesting was that although we had been told that the news of stoning in Mashhad had been published in the newspapers of the province of Khorasan (Mashhad is the capital of the Khorasan province), and we looked for the articles in all the newspapers that were published in May and June but we did not find any mention of the execution. That is why I had to go to Mashhad personally to investigate the matter. Once I was there I came to understand that the execution had been reported not as a death by stoning but as execution according to Sharia.

 

2- Who were the people condemned to death by stoning in Mashhad and what was their crime?

 

A woman named Ms. Mahboubeh M. and a man named Abass H. These two people were related to each other. Their crimes were murdering Mahboubeh’s husband, and committing adultery. I have to admit that it was a very gruesome murder, but the issue is not what kind of a crime they committed. To my knowledge none of the women’s rights activists deny that a criminal must be punished. But the issue is that the punishment should match the crime.

 

Death under showers of stones is under any circumstances a horrific death.  If we go by the rules of Sharia, the conditions that must exist in order to prove the crime of “ehsan”, adultery, are extremely difficult. The burden of proof is very high. Often it is more difficult to prove that such a crime has taken place than to acquit the criminal.

 

3-Were these two stoned to death for the crime of adultery or the crime of murder?

 

Stoning was the punishment for the crime of adultery. Ms. Mahboubeh did not kill her husband but she was an accomplice in his murder.

 

4-So what was their punishment for the crime of murder?

 

For the crime of being an accomplice, Ms. Mahboubeh was sentenced to 15 years in jail. Mr. Abass was the murderer and his sentence was “ghesas” (retaliation). In addition to the murder he had also committed the crime of adultery. So, stoning in fact is execution but it is an unusual form of execution. It means that these people could have received the sentence of execution instead of stoning. This is exactly what we ask of the law makers and lawyers, if the woman had not committed adultery, and had only been convicted of murder, there would have been a thousand ways of dealing with her punishment. The same goes for the man, if he had only been convicted of murder, under the rules of “ghesas” he could have obtained the forgiveness, the agreement of the parents or the relatives of the victim and paid the blood money, and solved the problem and maybe even he would have been freed. In Ms. Mahboubeh’s case after serving her 15 years in jail, she would have been freed. Therefore her death especially in this manner was precisely because she had committed adultery.

 

5- Did these two people have the right to a lawyer in court?

 

Yes. Both had lawyers. A court appointed lawyer, and I was able to speak to Ms. Mahboubeh’s lawyer.

 

6-Was the stoning done in public?

 

It is not exactly clear who was present at the stoning.  But it is evident that the stoning did not take place in public.  The Sharia law states that stoning must take place in public in order to teach others a lesson and discourage others from committing adultery.  The newspapers reported it as an execution not stoning, this surprised me because if the main point of stoning is to teach the public a lesson, then why hide the news of it?

 

7-Where did the stoning take place? 

 

It was done in Behesht Zahra, the grand cemetery of Mashhad on May 7th, 2006.

 

8-Do you have any information on the level of public participation in the stoning?

 

As far as my investigation of the files of these cases show, the public has not participated in stonings. At least after Mr. Shahroudi’s ban on stoning, I know that none had taken place in public. You should know that there is a difference between execution and stoning. An execution is carried out by officials of the judiciary system but in stoning, the act of stoning is carried out by ordinary people.

 

9- If the stoning was not done in public by ordinary people, then who carried out the stoning?

 

This is a good question for the government officials. If I knew who they were, I would have interviewed them myself; it would have been a very interesting interview.

 

10- Did you interview the judge in Mahboubeh’s case?

 

Yes I did interview him, but he did not give permission to publish the interview. Almost half of my time in Mashhad was spent on going from one office to another trying to obtain permission to publish interviews with no results.

 

11-My next question is about the family of the convicted. How do they deal with the sentence of stoning for their loved ones, do they try to save their lives? Or, because of the shame that is traditionally associated with sexual issues in our culture, do they shun the adulterous and not partake in any activity in their defense?

 

Let me respond to this question by reading what is written on Ms. Mahboubeh’s gravestone. The writing is powerful and made me think deeply. I tried very hard to find Ms. Mahboubeh’s children but they have moved out of the area and unfortunately I was unable to locate them. The writing is as follows:

 

My mother, you were my love and hope

You were my honor and pride

Whenever sadness filled me

You were my friend and inspiration

 

In my opinion what they wrote on the grave is indicative of the kind of relationship she had with her children. The family in a short time after her death already had installed a stone on her grave, and such a sincere and touching poem was written on it. To me this shows that her death was important to her children. Also legally in their role as plaintiffs in the case of their father’s death, they had forgiven their mother, they had agreed not to retaliate, not to punish her (the law of ghesas). But I have to add that this type of reaction from the family members is not always the case in all these situations. I saw the family of Ms. Iran A. in Ahvaz (a city in the south west of Iran), and based on what I saw, I think if and when she gets released from jail we will witness a horrifying honor killing in that family.

 

It is not always the case that the families forgive or call for the acquittal of the convicted person, in many parts of the country not even the families of the convicted will let go of the punishment much less the families of the murdered victims.

 

12-Please tell us about the case of Ms. Iran A?

 

After my trip to Mashhad I found out that there were two cases in Ahvaz where both people had been told, just like in Ms. Kolheri’s case, that their death by stoning sentence was to be carried out soon. Ms. Iran A. and Kh. V. have both requested to remain anonymous. I went to Ahvaz to see them. Both of these southern women have been sentenced to death by stoning for murdering their spouses. On one hand they are faced with the threat of being stoned to death and on the other hand they are threatened by their families. If they are freed from jail, their brothers would certainly kill them.

 

Of course in the case of Ms. Iran A., I think there is still a chance to defend her because her case does not really entail the crime of adultery. While her husband was alive she did not commit the act of adultery, the sex took place after he was dead. She claims that at the time of her husband’s murder she was unconscious. Despite these claims and information she was convicted of being an accomplice in murder and was sentenced to stoning.

 

13- Does this mean that if a woman kills her husband and has sex with her lover after her husband’s  death, she can not be stoned to death but if she commits adultery while he is alive then she can be sentenced to death by stoning?

 

Yes, of course, one of the conditions of adultery is when the husband is near [not away i.e. traveling] and the woman has sex with another person, then she has committed adultery and the punishment is stoning. If her husband is dead then the act of sex is not adultery, it is sex outside of marriage. According to the law, sex outside of marriage is considered illicit sex.

 

14- In your opinion, in the cases you have closely studied, are there any similarities between these women in any area i.e. their private life, economic class or age?

 

Some of the cases really had nothing in common, but in many of these cases, the issue at hand was “falling in love”. These women had fallen in love with somebody else without having the ability or the possibility of obtaining a divorce. In many situations the women had even filed for divorce but their request had not been accepted either by their spouse or the court.  Not all women condemned to stoning are from lower economic classes of the society, we have some cases of women from the upper economic classes too.  Falling in love has nothing to do with age or economic class.  

   

15- If possible please tell us about your trip to the city of Jolfa?

 

When I was in Ahvaz I heard that one of my lawyer friends had accepted the case of Ms. Hajieh Esmailvand. After I heard her life story, of which I had previously heard a little, I realized that we were dealing with one of the most peculiar women legal cases and that is why I went to Jolfa.

 

Ms. Hajieh’s case was very complicated. It was complicated because it was incomprehensible that her case had received such a grave sentence. At the time of her husband’s murder, she was out of town attending to her child’s illness, this was easily proved. We do not understand on what evidence the judge had charged her with the crime of being an accomplice in the murder. Ms. Hajieh explained in the court that the murderer had tried to rape her once but he had not been able to carry out the act of rape. However later in the court proceedings Ms. Hajieh had signed a piece of paper that constituted her confession to having committed adultery. According to Ms. Hajieh after her verdict had been issued and she had spent several years in jail, she still did not know the meaning of the word “rajm”. She recounts having asked her brother what does the word “rajm” mean and he explained to her that it meant stoning. You can see that it is obvious how the rest of the story goes.

 

16- Did Hajieh and the other women have lawyers? Or is it possible for the prosecution to continue without defense lawyers?

 

Yes, she also had a court appointed lawyer. In these cases if the defendant can not obtain their own lawyer, the court would appoint them a lawyer. In my opinion what is very important to know about these court appointed lawyers is that they seem to be indifferent about defending these criminal cases, and more specifically not interested in any of these kind of honor related cases. Such cases require a lot of follow up and investigation, and the lawyer really needs to be concerned about the case to do the work. In one of the cases, one of the judges told me “Even the defendant’s lawyer speaks of her with aversion and keeps telling me what is there to defend”.

 

Well, perhaps to solve this problem instead of the judicial system, the lawyers themselves can suggest a solution so those lawyers who are more motivated and involved can take on these cases.

17- You spoke of a “project” in relation to this reporting, would you please explain the idea of the project?

 

I started by doing simple news reports. I have many friends who like me are thinking of saving these women from being stoned to death, and even changing the law of stoning, and are ready to help. This includes my reporter and lawyer friends.  In my opinion, to change such a law, it is not enough to appeal to the law makers; it is necessary but not enough.

 

Preparation of case studies will help bring the public face to face with the reality and the consequences of such laws. Public opinion is only formed when faced and confronted with these cases, it is the job of the media is to inform and educate the public.  In a way what we are doing is not really a “project”.  What I mean by “project” is the process of gathering the information, identification and following the cases, helping to find lawyers and good defense and finally being able to publish it all and somehow all these activities have turned into a permanent collaboration.

 

18- Are there any other cases of stoning?

 

Unfortunately yes. There has been talk of a few cases but we have not been able to verify the accuracy of the news. There was a case in the city of Roodsar, another in the city of Tabriz, another in Yazd and yet another in Tehran. It will take a while to be certain about these cases and for the lawyers to be identified.

 

19- Are all the cases of stoning reported? Or can there be cases that even reporters are unaware of?

 

Well yesterday I heard that a stoning had been carried out in Yazd and the news of it has not been published anywhere. I still do not know if this news is true or not.

 

20-After your travels, all that you have heard and the interviews you have conducted, what is your personal opinion of the people who’s been condemned to stoning?

 

In my opinion they are receiving the gravest punishments of humanity. They have fallen in love. Their love is prohibited but their death is sanctioned by religious law. The penalty these people have paid for their forbidden love is unusually severe. I wonder if those who throw the stones have ever known love. Would they ever fall in love? Even love in its permitted form? It is true that these cases have not always been about love.  There was a case where a man had forced his wife into prostitution; however there are only a small number of these cases.

 

Men in this society have more rights and more freedom. They have control over permanent marriage, temporary marriage, divorce etc. and these one sided rights result in women becoming the victims of these tragic cases. Women are the ones facing barriers in obtaining divorce; these obstacles are legal, social and family related. After all they are humans made of flesh who can fall in love, and they pay for this forbidden apple with their lives.

By: Interview with Asieh Amini /By: Soheila Vahdati (Iran Emrooz)ý